Aesthetic Rightness? Neotraditional Architecture and Urban Design and the Aestheticization of Politics will consider the relationship between neotraditional architecture and urban design and political ideology.
This symposium is convened by Janina Gosseye, Isabelle Doucet and Reinhold Martin and will take place at the TU Delft Faculty of Architecture and the Built Environment on 1-2 April 2027.
Call for Papers
When in December 2020, near the end of his first term, American President Donald Trump issued an Executive Order for ‘Promoting Beautiful Federal Civic Architecture’, arguing that the use of ‘classical and other traditional architecture’ should be encouraged in the design of new federal buildings, it sent shockwaves through the profession. Within a week, nearly 11,000 architects had written to the White House opposing the proposed mandate, and the American Institute of Architects issued a statement that ‘communities should continue to have the right and responsibility to decide for themselves what architectural design best fits their needs’.
What this brief episode emphatically demonstrates is that neotraditionalism in architecture and urban design is divisive. At best it is associated with a type of (alt)right conservativism behind phenomena such as ‘tradwives’, while at worst it recalls the kind of despotism behind Nicolae Ceaușescu’s Casa Poporului.
Ironically, however, on either side of the Atlantic, neotraditionalism in urban design has roots in the 1960s and 1970s urban struggles for the right to the city. In the US, the origins of such thinking can be linked to Jane Jacobs’s resistant actions of the 1960s, when she defended New York’s blighted inner-city residents against Robert Moses’s top-down technocratic urban schemes. In Europe, key figures were Léon Krier and Maurice Culot who designed neotraditional counterprojects to support the ‘battles conducted by the workers … against the appropriation of the city by monopolies … and in active opposition [to] private and public speculation’.
In 1978, Krier outlined a Charter for the Movement for the Reconstruction of the European City, which was subsequently further elaborated and published as the Declaration de Bruxelles in 1980. This book, which was intended as a foil to the Athens Charter made direct connections between neotraditional urban design and leftist ideas and ideologies. For instance, chapter ten was called ‘Le Droit á la Ville’; an explicit reference to Henri Lefebvre’s famous 1968 book with the same title.
The guiding principles of American New Urbanism then, which borrowed heavily from Jacobs’s ideas, were elaborated in the 1999 Charter of the New Urbanism which, contrary to The Declaration of Brussels, shied away from political partisanship. For instance, in her preamble to the book, Shelley R. Poticha, Executive Director of the CNU, cited both Vice-President Al Gore, a democrat and outspoken environmentalist, and Christine Todd Whitman, the (then) Republican governor of New Jersey to underscore New Urbanism’s bipartisanship – or even political neutrality.
This political neutrality – or, more accurately, political opportunism – has worked to the CNU’s advantage. As Erik Mumford points out in Designing the Modern City: ‘New Urbanism […] has had an immense influence on American urban development over the past three decades.’ But also in Europe neotraditionalism (certainly in urban design) has become widely accepted, even as leading figures, like Krier, who aligned himself with Prince (now King) Charles and exalted the architectural achievements of Albert Speer, increasingly veered to the right.
In academia too, neotraditionalism in architecture and urban design has found champions, including Roger Scruton, Catesby Leigh, Emily Talen, David Watkin, and others, a number of whom have taken vocal political positions.
In this symposium, we are interested in contributions that consider the relationship between neotraditional architecture and urban design and political ideology. We also welcome papers that consider the work of those who have engaged in espousing and theorising this movement and papers that reflect on (those who have examined) correlations between aesthetics and political philosophy more broadly.
Organizers
Janina Gosseye is Professor of Building Ideologies and Head of the Building Ideologies Group (BIG) at the TUDelft Faculty of Architecture and the Built Environment. Her research is situated at the nexus of 20th century architectural and urban history on the one hand, and social and political history on the other. Her books include Urban Design in the 20th Century: A History (gta Verlag, 2021, with Tom Avermaete); Activism at Home: Architects Dwelling Between Politics, Aesthetics and Resistance (Jovis, 2021, with Isabelle Doucet) and Speaking of Buildings: Oral History in Architectural Research (Princeton Architectural Press, 2019, with Naomi Stead and Deborah van der Plaat). Gosseye is a series editor of the Bloomsbury Studies in Modern Architecture (with Tom Avermaete), and an Honorary Member of the Australian Institute of Architects.
Isabelle Doucet is Professor of Architectural Humanities at the University of Sheffield School of Architecture and Landscape. Her research focuses on the societal and environmental responsibilities of architects and urban designers, which she has studied through historical cases (with a focus on “after 1968”), theoretical revisiting, and through methods of inquiry. Doucet is currently preparing two book manuscripts: a research monograph offering an in-depth critical study of the portrayal of women as role models in architecture history, and, together with Hélène Frichot, an edited collection on environmental storytelling in architecture. Doucet is the author of The Practice Turn in Architecture. Brussels after 1968 (Routledge 2015) and editor of Activism at Home: Architects dwelling between politics, aesthetics and resistance(Jovis, 2021, with Janina Gosseye) and Transdisciplinary Knowledge Production in Architecture and Urbanism. Towards Hybrid Modes of Inquiry (Springer 2011, with Nel Janssens). She has also guest-edited several thematic journal issues including the “Resist Reclaim Speculate: Situated Perspectives on Architecture and the City” issue for Architectural Theory Review (with Hélène Frichot, 2018).
Reinhold Martin is a historian of media, architecture, and technology at Columbia University, in the Graduate School of Architecture, Planning and Preservation. His books include The Organizational Complex: Architecture, Media, and Corporate Space (MIT, 2003), which shows how architecture, the visual arts, and the social and natural sciences intersected with cybernetics to formed an organizing nexus within the post-World War II military-industrial complex; Utopia’s Ghost: Architecture and Postmodernism, Again (Minnesota, 2010), which returns to the architectural “ghosts” of utopian thought and praxis that survived the postmodern injunction against structural change; and Knowledge Worlds: Media, Materiality, and the Making of the Modern University (Columbia, 2021), a media history of American colleges and universities understood as a series of epistemological, technological, spatial, and symbolic boundary problems. A former, founding co-editor of the interdisciplinary journal Grey Room, Martin is also the co-editor with Claire Zimmerman of Architecture against Democracy: Histories of the Nationalist International(Minnesota, 2024).
Scientific Committee
- Janina Gosseye, TU Delft, The Netherlands
- Isabelle Doucet, University of Sheffield, UK
- Reinhold Martin, Columbia University, US
- Frida Grahn, London South Bank University, UK
- Samuel Stewart-Halevy, UCLouvain, Belgium
- Léa-Catherine Szacka, University of Manchester, UK
- Amy Thomas, TU Delft, The Netherlands
Dates and deadlines
- 15 January 2027: Submission of abstracts closes
- 1 February 2027: Notification of acceptance
- 1-2 April 2027: Symposium in Delft
Abstract submission
Abstracts of maximally 300 words and a bio of 100 words (per author) should be sent (as a word file) by email to j.gosseye@tudelft.nl
Please note that speakers will have maximally 20 minutes to present during the symposium.
Conference fee
Symposium attendees will be required to pay a registration fee of €100. Staff and students of the TU Delft Faculty of Architecture and the Built Environment can attend the talks given during the symposium for free.
Venue
The symposium will take place in person at the TU Delft Faculty of Architecture and the Built Environment in Delft (The Netherlands). Symposium attendees are responsible for covering their own travel expenses and accommodation costs in Delft.
https://aestheticrightnesssymposium.org/